Review: Caught By The Tides

Image courtesy of MK2 Films.

I've long admired and enjoyed the work of Jia Zhang-Ke, one of China's most highly acclaimed and prolific filmmakers whose work often employs a fiction-docudrama hybrid. His latest, "Caught by the Tides," should have been my cup of tea, considering that it features characters from some of his finest films, was shot over a period of many years (I've always been a sucker for movies that explore the passage of time as a theme), and features the melancholic and often beautifully shot imagery one would associate with a Zhang-Ke film.

With some works, what you get out of it has to do somewhat with what you bring to it - or, rather, how much of yourself you're willing to give to it. In this case, I'll fully admit that at times I wasn't completely following the film - which has an elliptical pattern, even for this director - or as invested in it as I have been with his other works.

This is not to say it's a bad film by any stretch of the imagination. In fact, I appear to be in the minority in terms of where I stand on it - which is this: I'd place it somewhere in the realm of Zhang-Ke's films that go heavier on the docudrama angle, such as "24 City" or "Swimming Out Till the Sea Turns Blue," both of which are movies that I'd rank lower in his filmography. 

The film has some of the startling imagery and moody editing and use of music that his best films - namely, "Ash is Purest White," "Platform," "Unknown Pleasures" or "Mountains May Depart" - utilize, but it didn't strike me in the quite the same way. It's entirely possible I could have a different experience watching it a second time (which I eventually might).

Suffice it to say, this film is significantly more elliptical than any of the other films I just praised. It starts in 2001 and ends somewhere during the COVID-19 pandemic (2022, I believe), and various characters pop in and out of the action. There's a fair amount of dancing and singing (karaoke and otherwise) and, as usual, Zhang-Ke's greatest concern is observing the vast changes that China has undergone over the past few decades.

There's an entire section set in 2006 against the backdrop of the Yangtze River, where the forced migration of citizens in the region occurred to make way for the installation of the Three River Gorges dam, a topic that the director covered extensively in his film "Still Life" (another good one).

The film, shot over two decades much like Richard Linklater's "Boyhood," basically follows the story of Qiaoqiao (Zhao Tao, a Zhang-Ke regular) as she pursues her missing lover, Bin (Li Zhubin). The picture's various eras can be distinguished by the film stock, which varies from grainy video during Aughts-era scenes to crisper images for sequences set in the present.

Qiaoqiao's character first debuted in Zhang-Ke's acclaimed 2002 film "Unknown Pleasures" and the way she's utilized in this film also recollects her work in "Still Life" and "Ash is Purest White." In some ways, "Caught by the Tides" plays like a greatest hits of the director's work, not only in terms of style and themes that he often explores, but also his cast members and characters.

As such, "Caught by the Tides" feels a little like a summary of his body of work - but, for me, it is a lesser entry. Not a bad movie, but not nearly as evocative as the great "Ash is Purest White," the moving "Mountains May Depart" or his early works that put him on the map, such as "Platform" or "Unknown Pleasures." Perhaps, the film deserves another try - but for now, it's an intermittently interesting work that feels like a minor film for a significant director.