Review: All We Imagine As Light

Image courtesy of Janus Films.

A film about sisterhood and creating one's own family when the one assigned to you has failed you, director Payal Kapadia's "All We Imagine as Light" is also a poetic city symphony - in this case, of Mumbai - and the best picture to come out of India in some time.

The movie is what one could call a slice of life, and indeed it starts out - and occasionally circles back to - what come off as documentary-like interviews with Mumbai citizens, who briefly tell of their circumstances, before diving into the story of its three main protagonists.

All three of the women at the center of Kapadia's film have, in some form or fashion, been let down by their families. There's Prabha (Kani Kusruti), a dedicated nurse whose husband from an arranged marriage has been living abroad and working in Germany for years. He rarely calls her and to describe the couple's relationship as estranged is accurate. Prabha is friends with Dr. Manoj (Azees Nedumangad), who is new to the city and is clearly taken with her - but she remains aloof to his overtures.

Prabha's roommate, the much younger Anu (Divya Prabha), who works at the same hospital as Prabha, is secretly seeing a young man named Shiaz (Hridhu Haroon) because her family would not approve of her dating a Muslim. The young couple sneak off for the occasional make-out session in the rain, but do not have anywhere where they can consummate their relationship.

Prabha's widowed friend, Parvaty (Chhaya Kadam) is in danger of being evicted from her home of many years after her now-deceased husband failed to leave her any information or documentation proving that the home is hers. She visits a lawyer who tells her that no evidence that she can provide will hold up in court. Nearby is a luxury property with a sign reading "Class is a Privilege Reserved for the Privileged." Prabha and Parvty toss rocks at the sign, putting holes in it.

The film's first half is primarily concerned with introducing these storylines, with the occasionally lovely flourish filled with haunting music that is accompanied by gorgeous night-time shots of Mumbai, teeming with life and filled with lights of varying colors.

In the second half, Prabha convinces Anu to help her to move Parvaty back to her seaside village, which sets all three women off on their own adventures. Unbeknownst to the others, Shiaz has followed them to the village, so he and Anu finally have a moment alone in the woods.

Meanwhile, Prabha stumbles upon a scene along the shore where an unconscious man is pulled from the water. She revives him, saving his life, and helps to place him in a house where he can rest. A woman tending to the room mistakes Prabha and the man as husband and wife, so Prabha - in one of the film's few mystifying moments - fantasizes that the man is her estranged husband, and carries on a conversation with him as if this were the case.

While the three women were somewhat adrift prior to this journey - Prabha seemed conflicted about her relationship with the kindly Dr. Manoj and spent more time than was healthy prying into Anu's love life, while Anu purchases a burqa for the purpose of sneaking into Shiaz's neighborhood for a tryst and Parvaty struggles with her possible eviction - a final stop at a cafe suggests that these three women, all disappointed with their actual families, might form one of their own.

"All We Imagine as Light," which is an impressive feature film debut, was one of the hits of this year's Cannes Film Festival and has made frequent appearances on year-end lists. It's easy to see why. This often luminous, gentle, and very well acted drama is of the type that sneaks up on you and works its magic. It's a subtle film - but like the city it depicts, it's teeming with life.